top of page

Trust in Leadership: When the Tooth Fairy Isn't Real

Writer: Jose Samayoa
Jose Samayoa
Nov 4
3 min read

Updated: Nov 5

Captions for a Career | Episode 2 Creating Culture: Tooth Fairy Isn't Real Moments by Executive Coach Jose Samayoa

Captions for a Career | Episode 2

Creating Culture: Tooth Fairy Isn't Real Moments

Topics: Trust, disappointment, and leadership behavior There is a particular kind of disappointment that comes from watching someone you respect fall short when it matters.

Maybe a leader promises support and disappears when the conversation gets uncomfortable. Maybe a company talks about its people being its greatest asset, then treats someone as disposable. Maybe you finally speak up and leave the conversation wishing you hadn’t.

You get a look behind the curtain, and the reality is very different from what you believed.

We call these “Tooth Fairy Isn’t Real Moments.” They happen when someone or something you hold in high regard fails to meet the expectations you had of them.

That is the focus of Episode 2 of Captions for a Career, the original audio series from Eels Professional Development. It’s a conversation about trust in leadership, disappointment at work, and the responsibility that comes with having people look up to you.

Listen to Episode 2 on YouTube. When someone you trusted lets you down

The disappointment can reach beyond the situation itself. You may start questioning your judgment, your place in the organization, or whether the culture you believed in ever really existed.

That can be a tough place to find yourself, especially early in your career.

A little perspective can help. One person’s behavior does not have to become your expectation of every leader you will ever work with. You can take what happened seriously, adjust your expectations, and still leave room for better experiences.

How you hear this episode may depend on where you are in your career. You might recognize the feeling of being let down. If you lead people, you may also recognize the weight of knowing that someone could feel that way about you. What to do after a Tooth Fairy Isn’t Real Moment When someone disappoints you at work, give yourself enough room to choose a response you can stand behind.

Start with what you know. Identify what happened, what you expected, and what still needs clarification. A direct conversation may help you understand whether you are dealing with a misunderstanding or a deeper problem.

Focus on what you can control. You can choose the questions you ask, the boundaries you set, and the support you seek. You can also decide how much trust someone’s actions have earned.

Take a deliberate next step. That might mean addressing the concern, changing an expectation, or reconsidering whether the environment is right for you. You do not have to solve your entire career in the heat of one disappointing moment.

Remember the feeling when someone needs you. The experience can become a useful reference point for your own leadership. When you promise support, receive difficult feedback, or respond to someone who is struggling, remember what it felt like to be on the other side.

You can carry the lesson forward without giving up on people. Where coaching fits into the conversation

These situations can be difficult to sort through when you are inside them. A confidential sounding board gives you room to examine your expectations, prepare for a difficult conversation, and consider how your response may affect the people around you.

Based in Farmington, Connecticut, Eels Professional Development provides one-on-one executive coaching, career coaching, and leadership development for professionals and organizations. Our work includes helping leaders communicate more effectively, address conflict, and think through the everyday decisions that shape workplace culture.

If this episode brings a situation to mind, connect with a coach to talk about what you are facing. Listen to Captions for a Career Episode 2

Captions for a Career brings Eels’ original written video captions into short audio episodes, released every Sunday to give professionals something to think about as they head into the workweek.

Episode 2 is Creating Culture: Tooth Fairy Isn't Real Moments, exploring trust, disappointment, and leadership behavior.

Real or not, what matters is what we learn and how we respond.

As you listen, consider this: What did your own Tooth Fairy Isn’t Real Moment teach you and how are you using that lesson with the people who trust you?

About the author: Jose Samayoa is the founder and principal of Eels Professional Development in Farmington, Connecticut. His coaching draws on experience in the U.S. Navy, corporate leadership, and small business operations. He holds an MBA from the University of Connecticut.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page